The Split on the Right: The Future of the American Experiment

The Split on the Right:  Laura Ingraham vs. Jennifer Rubin; The Future of the American Experiment: A Challenge For Us All  – AMERICA’s VOICEAMERICA’s VOICE:

Washington, DC – At a time when some pundits are attempting to divine a nonexistent civil war on the left, it seems to us that the divide on the right is of greater consequence.

With the GOP now the Party of Trump, there is still an active debate between those embracing the white nationalism of the President and right-of-center voices resisting Trump and fighting for a tolerant and pluralistic America. Today this debate shows up in sharp relief, as Laura Ingraham decries an America that is becoming increasingly diverse and Jennifer Rubin decries a Republican Party that has elevated xenophobia to a preeminent position within the party.

Here’s what they are saying:

Laura Ingraham: ‘America We Know and Love Doesn’t Exist Anymore’ in Some Places Because of ‘Massive Demographic Changes’

in some parts of the country, it does seem like the America that we know and love doesn’t exist anymore. Massive demographic changes have been foisted on the American people and they’re changes that none of us ever voted for and most of us don’t like. From Virginia to California, we see stark examples of how radically in some ways the country has changed. Now, much of this is related to both illegal and in some cases legal immigration that of course progressives love.

Washington Post’s Jennifer Rubin: “Trump is driving progressive and moderate Democrats together, not sparking a civil war”

…Republicans have elevated immigration — xenophobia, if you will — to a preeminent position in the party’s agenda. It’s more important to Trump and his base than virtually anything else. He talks about it incessantly, returns to the issue when things are going badly and manages to convert his anti-immigrant ideas into vivid portraits of suffering by innocents (be they “dreamers” or children of migrants). That infuriates not only minority voters but parents, employees in diverse workplaces and young voters who are coming to see the GOP not as merely wrong, but as cruel, racist and irrational. Trump may think pounding the drum on immigration is the way to save his party. More likely, it has been a key reminder of the values shared by voters outside his base.

Yes, reuniting America around shared values of tolerance, rationality, kindness and honesty may be the “backlash,” if you will, to Trump. Not in anger, but in disgust, Americans may be coming to their senses.

According to Frank Sharry, Executive Director of America’s Voice:

The American experiment is reflected in our national motto E Pluribus Unum – Out of Many, One. Originally meant to unite states into a union, it came to mean a united nation built from many strands of background, birthplace and creed. Imperfect and unfinished, the project is to forge a nation based not on common bloodline but on shared ideals.

That vision is newly threatened by a radical ultra-nationalism that views white populists as the real Americans and everyone else as ‘the other.’ Trump, Laura Ingraham and their like seem to want America to go back to a day when whites were on top, men dominated and everyone else submitted. Jennifer Rubin – and the majority of Americans – believe in an America that defines membership based on character and contribution, regardless of skin color, ethnicity, accent, gender, belief system, sexual preference and place of birth.

This November, it won’t just be candidates on the ballot. The contest will be between a political party that prioritizes race, power and privilege versus a political party that prioritizes equal opportunity regardless of race. For the sake of the American ideal, let us work to preserve our foundational values and endeavor to make them real in the lives of one and all.

Screen Shot 2018-08-08 at 3.32.45 PM

2 thoughts on “The Split on the Right: The Future of the American Experiment

  1. Melanie,

    We’re well aware of our own disagreements – it’s just that the Reaganites assumed that the rest of us were dead and gone. The utter failure of neo-conservatism changed that. Today, the pro-worker, military non-interventionists of the American Right have found their voice in Donald Trump and given the Koch Brothers the finger for wanting Open Borders so that they can get cheap labor in their industries in America.

    As much as you may dislike our views (except for military non-interventionism), I detest the other side of my own party far, far more than I disagree with President Trump, at least fiscally. Socially, I’m a hopeless social liberal who is quite happy promoting gay rights and really DOES NOT care about limiting abortions, at least not in the first trimester, when 77% of all abortions are performed. I don’t want to pay for 16 year old CHILDREN to have babies and have to drop out of high school and sentence themselves and their children to lifetimes of poverty. To me, THAT is the true Republican value and one that Libertarians used to agree with.


    1. How is the Republican Party ever going to recover from disassociating with the trump racist policy? The whittling away at progress on environment, the foreign affairs debacle, the stink of Putin buddy-up, the suspicion and taint of collusion, Trump Tower? , the alienation of friends? The immigration mess, separation of children etc etc etc? Is the republican Party going to be the Trump Party forever?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.